Irom Sharmila Vs. the Indian Army


Irom Sharmila Vs. the Indian Army


Switch on the TV it’s all about the IPL craze. Read the papers it’s all about match fixing. The news is all about cricket everywhere. And in other news, there was a protest in Delhi recently about Irom Sharmila’s deteriorating condition. Irom Sharmila for those of us who are not familiar with the name is called the Iron Lady of Manipur. She has been on a hunger strike since the year 2000. There is a criminal case against her for fasting- a case for attempted suicide. And the reason for her fast- simple – she just wants the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) removed from Manipur and all the north eastern states.

Now if you are still reading this and are curious about what the AFSPA is and does let me add a little explanation. Law and order is a police (State) subject in India- that is why in the movies you always see the commissioner of police reporting to the CM and not the PM. But the central government can interfere in the states business when it declares a particular state as a disturbed area and can send in the military. But when the military enters a civilian area they have no power to do what they do best- shoot down the enemy. That’s where the AFSPA comes- it grants full power to the military to act in a civilian area as if it’s under war. It can shoot down anyone with no questions being asked. Ordinarily this is not a problem when its militants and terrorists who are being hunted down. But sometimes innocent bystanders are also hurt- this is euphemistically termed as “collateral damage”. And that’s where the AFSPA plays a major role in protecting the army from lawsuits in civilian courts- in the high court or the Supreme Court for causing the deaths of innocent bystanders, shot accidentally.

Let’s get one thing clearly here; the blame clearly lies with the governments (successive) rather than the army. The army is a professional organization with clear rules of engagement- to shoot first and ask questions later- which is what their training equips them to do on the battlefields where they belong. Where they do not belong are civilian areas inside India. For an army which exists to shoot down Pakistanis and Chinese, to end up shooting Indians destroys the very credibility of the army. When an Indian citizen joins the Indian army, he doesn’t do it understanding that he may later be called on to shoot at fellow Indian citizens. To ask him to do that is to show that the Indian army has still not changed from the days of General Dyer and the Jallianwala Bagh massacre. And the person responsible for asking the army to do this, the government clearly shows that it is least interested in developing the police force to deal with internal threats while getting the army to do its dirty work.

So to come back to the premise of this post- what Irom Sharmila and other civil rights activists say is right- the AFSPA should go and without the cover of the AFSPA the army would naturally return to the borders where it belongs. The local police forces should be solely responsible for law and order inside India, as they are both trained and equipped for it and also because they are under the oversight of the courts to prevent any excesses. Unleashing the army on our own civilians and covering up their actions under the AFSPA is playing a self goal against the army and the country. But when have our politicians ever done the right thing for the country? They use the police for bandobast on roadways and use the army for police work.

And because large parts of our polity are inherently racist no one bothers about how the north eastern states are considered perennially disturbed while the heartland states with more incidents of violence are just law and order problems. Is it because we don’t trust the Border States? Or we don’t care what happens there? And I am not even talking here about Kashmir, I am just referring to states like Manipur or Nagaland where the armed insurgency is tribal in nature rather than jihadi. If large swathes of India is reeling under the Naxalite menace and still the government opts to use the CRPF in states like Madhya Pradesh and Andhra Pradesh, what prevents them from doing the same in the north eastern states?

There are two obvious solutions to this issue. The first one makes the most sense. Withdraw the army to the border where it belongs and leave the civilian areas to the proper authorities the police. The second and more painful option is to remove the fig leaf of the AFSPA cover and allow the army to operate like all civilian authorities in civilian areas- under the judicial oversight. To be accountable for excesses and to be prosecuted for unauthorized acts and to be held responsible for illegal orders. This will provide the solution the protesters in Manipur and other areas have been asking for- justice for victims. Unfortunately in our subcontinent we have a tendency to deify the armed forces- both Pakistan and India place the army on a pedestal and no one is allowed to question any excess because we are more patriotic than you. This kind of unthinking deification is what allows the Pakistani army to declare martial law again and again and the women of Manipur to stand up naked and hold placards saying “rape us Indian army”.

But the problem with us Indians is that we confuse patriotism with jingoism. We should support the legitimate acts of our government. But we are seduced by media campaigns which make us hyper-jingoistic on unfair issues. The AFPSA is a patently unfair law which only serves to damage the image of the army and destroy the faith of the peaceful citizens of India in one country/one law. But any criticism of this law means the hyper-jingoistic shouting brigades get into action defending the excesses under the guise of expediency. It’s as if repealing the law in the northeastern states would immediately lead to a declaration of independence from India. Is India so weak a nation that we need to terrify our population with the army to make them stay inside the union? What difference does democratic India offer to the British Raj which used to terrify the native population with the army and only used to rule by force and censorship? I believe that contrary to what we force fed by the pliant media and shrieking retired generals (on TV), India is a far stronger and unified country and need not fear its own citizens or threaten them with the armed forces.

And by the way I am also curious as to why the radical feminist brigades, who went hyper during the Delhi rape, fail to respond when the women who get raped are from Manipur or Nagaland or Mizoram? When women hold up placards asking the Indian army to rape them (shaming us all), shouldn’t the new defenders of feminism at least offer a pip or a sound-byte? I haven’t heard of any candle light vigils or TV shows discussing this. Have you? Irom Sharmila can starve to death for all that we care, for we are busy watching the fixed matches of IPL and showing our diehard support to CSK (as if they need us to). Makes one remember that old adage about common sense not being very common.

So what do you say? Should this unjust law called AFSPA be allowed to exist? Should Irom Sharmila and the women of Manipur get justice? Should the north eastern states be treated as part of India? Or should they be treated as enemy territory under occupation and to be pacified with the army? Let me know your thoughts, please…..

3 thoughts on “Irom Sharmila Vs. the Indian Army

  1. But there is absolutely no pressure from the Centre to enforce the AFSPA they’ll get the handouts either way. The local MLAs are disgustingly corrupt. If they want atrocities to be committed by those in their control they have their reasons. I agree the northeasterners don’t get to see the money but the MLAs the Netas do. And it’s very difficult to get the people to mobilize. For example today morning Irom Sharmila has a bail hearing where in theory she is freed to be given a fresh bail and fresh terms of imprisonment. How many turn up to support her it’s a round number you guess. They won’t do their part. And I don’t beleive it helps to enable them. They will scream about how Delhi oppresses them because if that’s true there is nothing they can do about it with only 3 MPs they have and only 2 they vote for. But if you point out they can demand their MLAs remove the black law, then they say oh its not that important or giggle and walk away. I have been to Manipur. Last time the police threatened to gang rape any hotel reception staff that gave me a room. It meant I had to go to a lot of different hotels. Everyone is interested in what a foreigner might be doing in Imphal but anyone I asked in return about Irom Sharmila just gave me a blank look said they didn’t know who she was and walked away. The people don’t know how much power they actually have. But it’s a pincer movement. Of course the law can be scratched from the Statute books if the Centre follows the advice of the many commissions it has set up to look into the matter. But until Manipuris take responsibility for their own politics they will always be oppressed. I think two weeks ago Tripura removed AFSPA from large swathes of Tripura. Congress will still give them huge handouts. There was not one criticism from any General. And it passed without note in Delhi like most of what happens or doesn’t happen in the northeast. I hope one person in Imphal turned up to support their Eche today if not I keep asking and hope for one who isn’t afraid just to do that. Stand beside her. Voting for what you believe in rather than for whomever gave you the biggest bribe is Politics M102. Let’s not run before we walk but as I say if I point out what hypocritical whores Manipuris are they stop listening and walk away. Hey you can put the point across more politely but I hope you put the point across they are not victims. It’s a democracy and Manipuris have the laws and only the laws that they vote for continually.

  2. Although you blame the centre it’s not true for the North East. Tripura decided last week to remove swathes of Tripura from the AFSPA by denotifying disturbed area status from those areas. It’s actually simpler than that. The Local State Governments have to notify disturbed area status in theory every six months but in Manipur they double up so once a year. Manipuris can on their own remove the AFSPA rid the land of the AFSPA and free Irom Sharmila but their support for her is a sham. They will not even stand beside her at Lamphelphat Court Complex every fortnight. When the Amnesty International Delegate came on 30 May bringing news that Amnesty International afer 12 years were considering formally adopting Irom Sharmila as a AI prisoner of conscience the local press were ordered to stay away so there are no paid media reports on that development. Although mainstream Indians do little for her they do far more for her than local Manipuris. She will gain far more publicity and access to media and supporters when she is returned to Delhi for day two of her trial then while she is in Imphal, Manipur held under an unconstitutional solitary confinement order and with the press and the people nowhere to be seen at her court hearings in Imphal. Thank you for writing about her. India is a democracy and the will of the people will prevail if they ever decide to express it.

    • Desmond thanks for your insightful comments….personally i have never been to any of the north eastern states and so i dont know the real ground level situation know there. but you dont need to see an atrocity personally to call it for what it is. I agree that the state governments could have played a more proactive role in removing these unjust laws. but we have to recall that they are dependant on the economic handouts the center provides to survive financially. he who pays the piper calls the tunes. the view from the southernmost part of India- where i reside is that the center doesn’t do much for the extremities- all politics is based on heartland states. the southern states were quick to cash in on the information technology boom and hence are financially independent the center to an extent. the other states like manipur, or nagaland or arunachal havent cashed in either industrially or economically or even educationally which alone will give them a loud voice to be heard in new delhi…finally, i love the way you talk about he will of the people being expressed soon..thats what we all hope for and are waiting for

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s